Re: Ruby On Rails on the iSeries -- WEB400

Ah Joe a voice of reason,
now if MORE people had only taken your approach "I'm just trying
to be a little voice of caution amongst the overwhelming wave of zealousness
that tends to surround new technologies, good or bad." when it came to VB,
C++, Java, and on and on and on, they all have been hyped as the "greatest
thing since sliced bread" <BTW what was the greatest thing BEFORE sliced
bread?) and would make programmers obsolete, etc etc.

But this is nothing new I think that thinking came in with the original RPG,
Report Program Generator for USERS!!!





On 8/17/06, Joe Pluta <joepluta@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:


> From: Tom Jedrzejewicz
>
> So don't use it.  Doesn't your tool make it easier for a person not
> familiar
> with (whatever) to develop systems that use (whatever)?  I am not sure I
> see the difference?

Actually, there is a bit of a difference in that my tool isn't about
developing business logic.  My tool is about quickly putting a
standards-based interface onto existing business logic.   RoR is being
hyped
(at least by some) as a complete enterprise development environment, and
that's the only thing I'm cautioning against.

Please, I'm not anti-RoR, just not convinced it's the answer to all IT
ills.


> Some businesses may use these platofrms, and accept the risk that goes
> along with having applications developed by someone other than IT.

Yes they may.  But there aren't a lot of companies using Excel as their
transaction processing environment.  There is a reason that SMBs go from
Excel and Peachtree to midrange ERP systems as they grow.  The intricacies
of business logic can be daunting even for programmers, much less people
who
have no training in IT procedures.  In the perfect world, you have
subject-matter experts (non-programmers) who talk to IT implementers
(programmers); the IT staff insulates the subject-matter experts from
things
like security and internationalization and change management.  There are
some in the RoR community who seem to think that RoR can supplant a full
enterprise stack like J2EE or ILE.

I may be something of an elitist; I'm still of the mind that dynamic
typing
in the hands of a non-programmer leads to systems that are less
maintainable
and more prone to systemic bugs that are difficult to track down and fix.
RoR may well prove me wrong, and I'll be happy to see it.  I'm just trying
to be a little voice of caution amongst the overwhelming wave of
zealousness
that tends to surround new technologies, good or bad.

Joe


--
This is the Web Enabling the AS400 / iSeries (WEB400) mailing list
To post a message email: WEB400@xxxxxxxxxxxx
To subscribe, unsubscribe, or change list options,
visit: http://lists.midrange.com/mailman/listinfo/web400
or email: WEB400-request@xxxxxxxxxxxx
Before posting, please take a moment to review the archives
at http://archive.midrange.com/web400.